Pay Less Income Tax in Retirement

Ruvan J Grobler • September 25, 2024

The below is a basic scenario I recently worked on for a client. The individual had around R7mil in the specific Retirement Annuity and needed R55k per month after tax as income from it. One of his concerns was if he should take the 1/3 lump sum allowed or if he should reinvest his entire retirement savings in a post-retirement structure. The below looks at these two scenarios.

 

There are many complexities around structures, disallowed contributions, asset allocation and income percentages that are ignored and simplified in this example.

 

  • Scenario 1:
  • Invest full retirement savings in post-retirement product.
  • First year income: R77 000 (R924 000 annually)
  • After tax: R55 062 (R660 744 annually)
  • Monthly tax payable: R21 938

 

  • Scenario 2:
  • Take R900 000 in cash and reinvest in flexible investment.
  • Lump sum after tax: R825 300
  • Voluntary income from lumpsum : R10 000 (R120 000 annually, no income tax on withdrawal)


Retirement Lump Sum tax table:

  • First year income from 2/3 retirement portion: R60 450 (R725 400 annually)
  • After tax: R45 077 (R540 924)
  • Monthly tax payable: R15 373

 

Income: R45 077 + R10 000 = R55 077 per month

 

Difference in income tax paid in scenario 2 compared to scenario 1: R6 565 per month (R78 780 annually)

 

The real tax saving starts from year two as you also take the lump sum tax into account in year one (R78 780-R74 700). The reinvestment of the lumpsum cash does also provide you with flexibility and extra cash flow if needed. A lower income need will provide a larger income tax saving, which is probably the more important lesson to learn here.

 

A comprehensive retirement plan is extremely important and professional advice is a necessity.

 

Ruvan J Grobler RFP™ (PGDip Fin Planning)


By Bovest April 4, 2025
The widely anticipated tariffs were announced last night via executive order, on America’s so-called ‘Liberation Day’ and in discussions with our partners at Morningstar, the following should be noted. The sweeping announcement is intended to ‘make America wealthy again’ as tariffs effectively tax foreign producers on their imported goods, as a percentage of their value. The US is currently the largest goods importer in the world and is currently running a trade deficit (imports more than it exports). President Trump has said that he will not negotiate, however, if countries are willing to lower their charges on US goods, the White House will reduce the rate in effect. Market impact US Equities have sold off sharply, particularly those reliant on imported goods, as well as foreign companies that have significant exposure to the US market. At the time of writing, the FTSE 100 was down 1.4% to below 8,500, whilst sterling had appreciated to 1.32 against the dollar. Bond prices have broadly risen as investors have sought perceived safer assets. SA equities and bonds responded negatively after markets opened. The All-Share was down around -3,5% by end of-day with the decline being led by Financials at -4.3%, while both Resources and Industrials were down approximately -2.4%. The yield on the SA 10-year government bond spiked sharply to 11.3%, a move of 0.8% off the previous day's close. The rand remains relatively range-bound between R18.60 – R18.80 despite general US dollar weakness against most major currencies. What we know about the Tariffs: The tariffs that were imposed last night are of a reciprocal nature, meaning that countries are free to retaliate with their own tariffs on the US. Below are some of the standout tariffs that Trump has imposed across the globe: · China 34% · India 26% · Japan 24% · EU 20% · UK 10% South Africa, which currently applies 60% tariffs on the US, was handed a 30% reciprocal tariff. The effective rate is likely to be lower given that key commodity exports, including gold and platinum, are currently exempted. What we don’t know President Trump has not made it clear whether the tariffs will remain in place indefinitely and whether indeed they will remain at the initial level. There are many factors that could impact their longevity, including legal ramifications and future election implications. It is also yet to be seen how and when other countries will react to these changes. Countries may look to increase their current tariffs on the US or indeed may consider reducing them. Additionally, President Trump has stated that the only way to gain exemption from the tariffs is to set up factories and build products in the U.S., so we await to see how countries and companies react to this proposition. What’s next? While volatility and policy uncertainty will likely persist in the short term, we recommend investors keep a cool head. The challenge is to avoid overreacting to the elevated day-to-day volatility and remain focused on your financial plan. Central Banks have been in a holding pattern in anticipation of actions taken by President Trump, and therefore this announcement may have an impact on future Central Bank policy and interest rates. From a longer-term perspective, we may see implications for economic growth across various regions, however, it is too early to tell at this stage. From an investment standpoint, we continue to focus on the fundamentals, maintaining a long-term mindset, whilst paying attention to valuations. Market volatility can provide investors an opportunity to rethink their portfolios and find some better-valued investments with more attractive returns, however, it’s important to note that while selloffs will produce bargains, investors shouldn’t buy simply because stocks look less overvalued. Investment is always full of uncertainty, and therefore the Bovest solutions are constructed with this in mind. Valuations are key in our decision-making process, whereby our research process identifies return drivers from oversold assets, offering investors a high margin of safety. Against that, we also hold defensive assets that can add ballast to portfolios during periods of turbulence, including high quality government bonds and defensive equities such as consumer staples. Diversification continues to be a strong portfolio strategy in these times of uncertainty. Regards,  The Bovest Team
By Riaan Botha April 3, 2025
Inleiding Aftrede is onteenseglik ’n belangrike fase in ons lewens, en waarskynlik die belangrikste. Dit is die kulminasie van voorafgaande fases, soos opleiding en inkomsteskepping, en as ons nie gereed is vir hierdie fase nie, kan die lewe traumaties wees. Aftrede verg beplanning en beplanning is die gevolg van goeie gewoontes. Ons raad aan afgetredenes en mense wat beplan om af te tree, is om goeie gewoontes te kweek om hulle op die pad na ’n gelukkige aftrede te lei. Uit ons interaksie met kliënte wat op aftrede staan of reeds afgetree het, kon ons sien dat hierdie benadering prakties en logies is, met positiewe, tasbare gevolge. Baie faktore speel ’n rol in ’n gelukkige aftrede. In die VSA het ’n studie hierdie faktore gelys as goeie gesondheid, finansiële sekuriteit, liefdevolle familie en vriende en ’n doelgerigte of beplande aftrede - What Retirees Want. Dychtwald and Morison, 2022. p115. Hierdie aspekte word onder meer in hierdie boek aangespreek. By Bovest word kliënte se persoonlike omstandighede in ag geneem wanneer hulle finansiële advies vra. Ons wil mense help om hul finansiële situasie ten beste te benut om gelukkig te kan leef. Om gelukkig af te tree is egter nie ’n gegewe nie. Jy benodig persoonlike doelwitte wat opgevolg moet word met die begeerte om die nodige regte gewoontes aan te leer. Dit vereis dikwels dat jy bereid moet wees om van jou gevestigde gewoontes te verander. In die soeke na jou persoonlike geluk gaan jou gewoontes uniek wees. Hoe word Gewoontes Gevorm? Daar bestaan verskillende teorieë oor hoe om gewoontes suksesvol te vorm. By Bovest vind ons aanklank met James Clear se teorie soos vervat in sy boek Atomic Habits (Penguin Random House, London, 2018, pp47-48), wat vier stappe tot sukses verwoord: Stap 1: Raak bewus van ’n wenk, insig, doelwit of begeerte. Stap 2: Hunker om dit uit te voer. Stap 3: Wat is die reaksie wanneer jy dit uitvoer? Stap 4: Wat is jou beloning as jy dit uitvoer?  Kom ons kyk na’n voorbeeld van gewoonte-vorming: · Stap 1: Iemand wat aftree se doelwit is om waarde vir geld te soek – hulle ontleed voortdurend die omgewing waarbinne hulle leef en pas hul begrotings en maandelikse uitgawes oppersoonlike behoeftes voortdurend aan. · Stap 2: Daar word navorsing gedoen oor watter uitgawe die beste waarde vir die beskikbare geld bied. · Stap 3: Die aankope word aangepas en die afgetredene voel tevrede dat daar waarde vir geld verkry is. · Stap 4: Aangesien daar binne begoting opgetree is, is die beloning dat daar fondse beskikbaar is om op ander beplande aankope te spandeer. Indien die koop ’n winskoop was, kan ons daarmee spog en selfs deur ons vriende geprys word as ’n winskopie-jagter! Deur hierdie vier stappe te herhaal, sal ons in die toekoms met meer gemak optree tot gewoontes van gesonde finansiële bestuur redelik moeitevry gevorm word.
Share by: